top of page

Israel Gap Year students & Parents

Part 1 discusses behavioral health and emotional development during the Israel gap year. It is compiled based on extensive experience working with gap-year programs, staff, students and parents

Part 2 discusses my work with gap year students

Total read time: 120 seconds

For many families, a year in Israel is supposed to be a year of growth.

​

Your child may have been looking forward to it for months. You may have imagined them becoming more independent, developing meaningful friendships, growing religiously, and beginning to figure out who they are away from home.

​

Often, that does happen, but a gap year in Israel is also a much bigger psychological transition than it may first appear. Students leave behind parents, schools, familiar routines, therapists, doctors, close friends, and the basic scaffolding that has helped organize their lives. At the same time, they enter an intense peer environment, gain much more freedom, and are expected to manage themselves in ways they may never have had to before. Even healthy, successful students can become temporarily disorganized under that combination of freedom, social pressure, reduced structure, and rapid change. Sometimes the anxiety over the transition and pressures can start in senior year, even before the particular seminary, yeshiva, or program is chosen.  That does not mean something has gone wrong; it means that the year asks a lot of them.

​

The challenges are often more ordinary than they look- and more important than they seem

​

A student who was perfectly capable at home may suddenly be responsible for getting around an unfamiliar country, managing money, dealing with food, appointments, transportation, sleep, and daily logistics without the same parental backup. Those small things matter. When a student is already anxious or overwhelmed, something as ordinary as figuring out a bus route, making Shabbos plans, or dealing with a difficult roommate can begin to carry much more emotional weight.

​

Dormitory life adds another layer. Students are living in close quarters for months at a time. There is less privacy, more social exposure, more opportunity for comparison, and fewer places to retreat after a difficult interaction. Roommates, noise, hygiene, boundaries, sleep, friendships, and social position can become surprisingly central to a student’s emotional life.

​

And then there is the social world itself. For some students, figuring out where they belong becomes one of the central tasks of the year. They may worry about who their real friends are, whether they are being included, whether they are too pushy or not assertive enough, whether they are “the weird one,” or whether everyone else has somehow found their place more easily.

​

In yeshiva, status may quietly become tied to chavrusa placement, rebbe attention, roommate dynamics, or how someone is perceived by peers. In seminary, friendship groups and subtle social cues can become a constant source of uncertainty. None of this is unusual, but for a student who is already vulnerable to anxiety, rejection sensitivity, depression, perfectionism, trauma responses, disordered eating, executive-functioning difficulties, or unstable relationships, the transition can expose difficulties that were easier for them to manage at home.

​

Israel does not erase the problems a student brings with them

​

There can be a fantasy surrounding the year in Israel. Sometimes students hope they will become a completely different person once they arrive. Parents may hope that distance from home will force maturity. Therapists may imagine that a new environment will solve an old problem.

​

Usually, it does not work that way- students tend to bring their familiar patterns with them. The anxious student may still be anxious, except now without the same supports. The perfectionistic student may become intensely invested in having the “right” year. Someone who depends heavily on parents may find the separation especially difficult. Someone who struggles with self-regulation may have more freedom and less external structure than ever before.

​

That does not mean the year cannot be transformative, it means that growth is usually less dramatic and more uneven than people imagine. A healthy year may include excitement, loneliness, inspiration, disappointment, mistakes, homesickness, conflict, repair, and gradual ownership of one’s choices. Transition stress is not necessarily a sign that the year is failing.

​

There are predictable points when students are more vulnerable

​

Students do not usually begin struggling at random. The weeks before departure can bring anxiety that is partly hidden by excitement. Afterwards, the first month or so in Israel can be socially overwhelming and physically exhausting. Students are meeting people constantly, sleeping poorly, trying to establish an identity, and often pushing themselves very hard.

​

Shabbos and Yamim Tovim can be unexpectedly difficult, especially when a student does not know where they are going or feels that everyone else has somewhere to be.

​

The novelty usually starts wearing off just after succos. This is often when exhaustion, homesickness, disengagement, or depression become more visible. 

​

Trips home can be destabilizing in another way. Students may feel as though they no longer fit completely at home but do not yet feel fully settled in Israel.

​

By the middle of the year, some students who managed to hold things together during the beginning are no longer able to do so. That is one reason it is important not to wait for a crisis before thinking about support.

​

Parents are going through a transition too.

​

The student is not the only one who has to learn a new role- Parents do as well.

​

At home, you probably knew much more about your child’s day-to-day life. You could tell when something was off. You knew their friends, could see whether they were sleeping, could make a doctor’s appointment, talk to the school, or simply walk into their room. Now you may be several thousand miles away trying to interpret a WhatsApp message or a late-night phone call. Moreover, you may be left wondering how much to intervene, or even if to intervene at all! After all, a new developmental stage has been entered. 

​

Then there are all the new questions:

  • How much homesickness is normal?

  • Should you intervene when they are having trouble with a roommate?

  • Should you contact the seminary or yeshiva? 

  • What if they call crying but tell you not to get involved? 

  • What if they stop calling altogether? 

  • How much should you push them to solve problems themselves? 

  • And how do you know when “giving them space” has crossed over into leaving them without enough support?

​

There is no single formula. Part of the developmental work of the year is learning to function without parents solving every problem. At the same time, there are situations in which parents absolutely do need to step in. The challenge is distinguishing between the two.

​

For parents, this often means making the shift from being  immediate problem-solvers to supportive coaches, while remaining ready to become more involved when there are serious concerns involving safety, major deterioration, eating-disorder risk, suicidality, substance misuse, or significant conflict with the program. And that balance can be difficult to find from overseas.

​

Continuity of care matters

​

This is especially important when your child was already receiving mental-health care before coming to Israel. A surprisingly common pattern is for a student to leave for Israel after months or years of therapy and simply stop treatment.

​

Sometimes that works- sometimes the student genuinely is doing well and no longer needs regular therapy. But sometimes the assumption is simply that Israel will provide a fresh start- and then, several months into the year, the student begins to unravel and suddenly needs urgent local care. That is a much harder time to begin searching for a therapist, as therapists’ caseloads tend to fill up as the school year progresses.

​

For students with a significant treatment history, it is often worth planning in advance.

That may mean connecting with an Israel-based therapist before the year begins, arranging communication between the therapist at home and the therapist in Israel, identifying who on program staff should know about important concerns, making sure psychiatric follow-up is available, and deciding ahead of time what should happen if certain warning signs appear.

​

Continuing with a therapist back home by Zoom may sometimes make sense for students who are functioning relatively well. For other students, however, particularly those who may be psychologically more vulnerable, therapy with their US therapist over zoom may present real obstacles to care- time-zone differences, scheduling issues, lack of privacy for session, and the therapist’s distance from the resources available in Israel can make local treatment much more critical. It is therefore important to establish appropriate care before a student is in crisis, when there is time to build rapport and coordinate appropriately.

​

Continuity of care does not necessarily mean keeping everything exactly the same- it means making sure the transition in treatment is planned thoughtful rather than rushed.

​

What helps students adjust well?

​

The students who do best are not necessarily the ones who never struggle. They are often the ones who can struggle without interpreting the struggle as proof that everything is falling apart.

They can ask for help, tolerate some uncertainty in friendships, accept correction without experiencing it as humiliation, and can recover from disappointment.They are able, gradually, to take more responsibility for their choices, and they can allow the year to be meaningful without demanding that it be perfect.

​

Those capacities can be developed- and in this regard therapy can often be an inseparable part of the growth process. Students benefit from learning how to regulate emotions, tolerate distress, ask for help, advocate for themselves, manage conflict, build routines, protect sleep, navigate friendships, and respond to setbacks without turning them into a full collapse.

I work with yeshiva and seminary students, and other young adults studying for extended periods in Israel. Sometimes a student comes with a problem that clearly predates the year: anxiety, depression, social or relationship difficulties, trauma, perfectionism, self-harm, suicidal thoughts, emotional instability, or a history of previous treatment. Other times, the circumstances of the gap year expose problems that had not previously caused much difficulty.
 

For some students, therapy is part of the overall process of development that takes place during the year. My work with students takes into account their unique developmental stage; they are emerging adults, newly independent and navigating life responsibilities on their own, while at the same time still dependent on parents and educational systems for structure, boundaries and direction. To that end, it is important for therapy to facilitate students' development of independence, autonomy, and responsibility while taking into account that family or progarm coordination may play a critical role.

​

Sometimes the work is relatively focused while at other times the work may need to go deeper. My style is active and collaborative. I try to understand what is actually happening, what patterns the student brought with them, how the Israel environment may be intensifying those patterns, and what needs to change for the year- and life beyond the year- to become more manageable.

Therapy must support development rather than replace it; the goal is not for the therapist to become another parent managing the student from the outside.

​

How I work with parents

​

Parents often need guidance of their own. Sometimes I meet with parents who are looking for consultation regarding their child who is in treatment with another therapist. When feasible, and with care to protect the student’s confidentiality, I coordinate with the student’s therapist and the seminary or yeshiva to help parents play an effective role in their child’s emotional growth during this critical year. Sometimes their child is already in treatment with me and we need to think together about what degree of parental involvement will actually help. 

​

That may involve helping you decide when to step back, when to encourage your child to use local supports, when to contact staff, how to respond to repeated crises, or when a situation has become serious enough that more active intervention is needed. There is an important difference between helping your child become independent and leaving them alone with something they are not currently able to manage, and part of my role can be helping families find that line.

​

I do not automatically involve parents in every detail of an older adolescent or young adult’s therapy. All therapy needs adequate confidentiality  in order to be effective. At the same time, I do not believe that privacy means pretending parents are irrelevant. When parental involvement is necessary and appropriate, I include parents in ways that support treatment and the student's confidentiality.

​

How I work with yeshiva/seminary/program staff

 

One of the advantages of working with someone in Israel is that treatment can happen within the environment the student is actually living in. When necessary and appropriate, and with attention to confidentiality and consent, I coordinate with madrichim, madrichot, rebbeim, teachers, program administrators, psychiatrists, previous therapists, and other professionals involved in the student’s care. 

 

This can be especially important when a student is struggling significantly. Without coordination, parents may assume the program is watching something that staff do not know about. Program staff may assume a therapist is handling concerns outside the therapist’s role. A therapist at home may have no idea what the student’s daily functioning looks like in Israel and may not easily have access to the right local supports. When a student's problems overwhelm program staff or significantly impact a student's ability to function, it can result in the program asking the student to leave. The goal is not for everyone to know everything, it is for the right people to know what they need to know, and for there to be clarity about who is responsible for what. Everyone involved is ultimately on the same team- we all want the student to have a successful year, and in my role I try to facilitate effective coordination and communication.

​

When should you reach out?

​

The most helpful coordination happens before the year begins- especially when there is a history of significant anxiety, depression, self-harm, eating problems, trauma, or psychiatric treatment.

Sometimes it happens a month into the year when you are not sure whether what you are seeing is a normal adjustment or the beginning of something more serious.

​

And sometimes your child has already been struggling for a while, and you simply need someone local who understands both mental health and the realities of the yeshiva/seminary environment.

Either way, we can begin with a brief consultation. You can tell me what has been happening, what your child’s history has been, what support is already in place, and what you are worried about. From there, we can think together about what kind of help would make the most sense.

bottom of page